💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

DonnaS (Tennessee)
Posts: 5,671
Posted:

The home page has this article so I copied it with hopes for a lively discussion here. The President Elect in his first speech asked that every American get ready to help with sacrifices that we will all have to make in solveing the energy problems along with other issues but we won't address that stuff.

This is interesting because where I live, the mayors have created a "green" coalition and are implimenting every way possible to help the city and county to go "green". 55 gallon plastic barrels are donated to any resident that is interested in retrofitting the barrels into rain barrels. The Master Gardeners are teaching classes and doing the retrofits.

So the discussion is how far should we be allowed to conserve. Many States have got laws on the books for HOA limits on restricting conservation methods but it still seems that HOAs want to make it difficult for the owners to impliment.

DON'T FORGET, THE CAROLINAS HAVE BEEN IN A 2 YEAR SEVERE DROUGHT

" While rain barrels conserve water, not everyone at St. Ives is happy about them. The St. Ives Homeowners Association newsletter says it all.
"The installation of these barrels will not be permitted in front of any property."
That's right. The HOA says rain barrels are not allowed in front of homes, even though Von Hedrich uses shrubbery to camouflage them.
"I wouldn't want to look at something that's an eyesore, but if you can't see it, then what's the problem?" Von Hedrich said.

Neighbor Franklin Clark said, "Anything to save water, rain barrel, or bath tub, I would be in favor of it."
Neighbor David Lang added, "I'm for it. Anyone who saves water."
Neighbor Lou Toffaletti disagreed, "I just think it would look tacky."
Von Hedrich says she feels the HOA is making up the rules as they go.
"I think there are a few in charge. I think there's some personal issues involved," she said. "I've been very frustrated in this community and I think some of that has been backlashed on us."

The HOA president didn't want to talk on camera. While there's nothing in the rules, he e-mailed us a statement saying, "The association supports water conservation ... Installations will not be permitted on the front of any property. They will be permitted on the rear of the house only."
SheliaH (Indiana)
Posts: 6,963
Posted:
I live in a townhouse community and have a container garden on my patio. Since the outdoor faucet is too far away for one of those irrigation drip systems, I've considered getting a rain barrel, so this topic is quite timely.

As far as this story is concerned, I think the HOA is being a tad unreasonable - if shrubbery does a good job in shielding the rain barrels, what's the problem?

I don't think our HOA's CCRs address rain barrels, but I do think it's a good time to look at them and see if anything needs tweaking to promote "green living" - especially if it'll save the homeowner and association money (and then, maybe the homeowners would pay their assessments in full and on time!)

We don't water the lawns (that's left to Mother Nature or the homeowner can use his/her own sprinkler). I suppose rain barrells would be ok if they stayed within the homeowner's patio. We probably wouldn't allow them to be attached to the gutters - there ARE some varieties that collect water without being attached to the gutter. I would also think there should be some requirement that the homeowner ensure there's no standing water, so the rainbarrell doesn't become a breeding ground for mosquitos (we've had some West Nile cases around her).


If it is not right do not do it; if it is not true do not say it. Marcus Aurelius
DonnaS (Tennessee)
Posts: 5,671
Posted:

Sheliah,

Thanks for the good response. Another issue in rain barrell use is WHERE IS THE DOWNSPOUT AND WHICH ONE GIVES THE MOST RUNOFF? These are all factors in where to place them, just as dish antennas need to work efficiently from the right location. I am a certified rain barrel ambassador for Hamilton County, which the mayor designated our group as we do the traveling to locations for teaching. I think that this is another future issue for all HOAs to deal with (unless you live in Hawaii or Washington State)
DanaB1 (Connecticut)
Posts: 319
Posted:
Sheila brings up a great point, standing water.........mosquitoes, west nile, etc.

The problem "we" would have here, much like those in Alabama, Mississippi and such is that some of our residents might consider these barrels to be a "poor man's hot tub". And I do have some neighbors that I'd rather not see naked getting in and out of them. On the other hand..................there are those few.........

Seriously though Sheila has me wondering with the whole "standing water" issue. Anyone have the barrels now and wish to comment?

Dana
DanaB1 (Connecticut)
Posts: 319
Posted:
Okay Donna, now you really have me wondering..........

What did it take to become a "certified rain barrel ambassador for Hamilton County"? You have way too much free time on your hands girlfriend.

Dana
DonnaS (Tennessee)
Posts: 5,671
Posted:

You asked for comments? Well, you got me. The rain barrels that we are using are NOT open at all. They have very tightly sealed lids, therefore, there is no standing water. The top is drilled with a hole, just large enough to insert one of those plastic gutter, accordion type, extensions. When inserted, it is glued with a plastic adhesive and that is attached to the rain gutter downspout. The bottom of the barrels have the hose spigot, where you attach a hose, long, short or whatever the need.

We are starting a contest where a certain age school class(not yet determined) will get a barrel, paint it and then enter it in a city contest. We havenot determined the prize yet but it will be for the entire class.
BrianB (California)
Posts: 2,820
Posted:
As this thread has reached it's sixth post, it will now be closed per RW's wishes.

any further postings here will be redundant, self serving, or useless.

this is a public service announcement brought to you on behalf of others.
DanaB1 (Connecticut)
Posts: 319
Posted:
H2O Ambassador,

How big are these barrels? Are they like white plastic 55 gallon drums or what?

And I'm still waiting to hear how many hours of schooling it takes to be an Ambassador. I'd like to be an Ambassador or something as opposed to just being considered an "a$$". Are any of you starting to wonder how my board puts up with me? Did I mention I don't have many friends?

Dana
MaryA1 (Arizona)
Posts: 7,043
Posted:
Donna,

I would just love to have a rain barrel because that would mean we do get rain! As you know, AZ is NOT noted for our rainfall!

BTW, I always heard rainwater is the best thing to wash one's hair in. But, of course, that may only have applied to the days when rainwater wasn't polluted!
DonnaS (Tennessee)
Posts: 5,671
Posted:

Dana,

These are 55 gal semi clear/white barrels with lids that the city gets some type of non harmful chemical in. The city donates them to our local food bank where this project originated with the Master Gardener program because we do many garden things for them. The Mayor got involved in the "Green City" program and sanctioned the use of city locations for setting up classes to teach. To be "a certified" rain barrel ambassador, you have to be a Master Gardener and teach retrofitting of the barrels. The certificate is a cute little piece of paper that we created.

Now the subject of having them look bad or intrusive in the landscape, many M.Gs have painted them the same color as their houses and I am a painter, having done one that looks like Monet's Waterlilly Pond" Some have birds, flowers, weeds or whatever one likes. It actually has become great fun.And we cannot wait to get the schools involved which will happen after the January new classes start.
DanaB1 (Connecticut)
Posts: 319
Posted:
That sounds great Donna, you are a breath of fresh air. And you definitely are coming up with new ideas to fix old problems.

Way to go.

Dana
DonnaS (Tennessee)
Posts: 5,671
Posted:

Dana,
Yes, but it took me more than our 6 post limit, oops!
JohnK3 (Pennsylvania)
Posts: 967
Posted:
I need a technical interpretation of the RW RULE: Is the limit 6 total replies to an OP, or is it 6 replies by a given correspondent?

Anyway, we are currently using a rain barrel. Actually, a big garbage can, but rain barrel sounds more…sophisticated.

Apparently, in violation of our ByLaws, a resident bird not only built a nest in one of our 2nd floor rain gutters, but also did not remove it after its chicks, if any, had taken flight. Said nest, having become compacted after a few rains, managed to block normal egress for future water, causing said water to flow over said gutter onto the ground, from which location it soaked in adjacent to our poured cement concrete foundation. Said soaking, in turn, coupled with the natural expansion cracks in said foundation and unusual stress placed on the rubber wall, led to serious leakage into our basement.

After a Chinese fire drill including the home warranty company, the builder, the rubber wall manufacturer and the installer of said rubber wall/foundation, I am happy to report that, though under no contractual obligation, Owner of installer dropped by, gave it a look, and sent someone out a day later to fix all three of our leakage points. A +3 hour undertaking. No charge.

“Why?” I asked Owner.

“Because I don’t like it when any of my work turns out less than excellent.”

You could have knocked me over with a feather. So rare an occurrence.

And tomorrow, up an extension later to remove said obstruction. And if I find that bird, you can bet there’s going to be a fine leveled.

Note: My use of the term “Chinese fire drill” is in no way meant as a racial/ethnic slur, and my apologies to anyone taking offense.
DanaB1 (Connecticut)
Posts: 319
Posted:
Thank you so much for your story JohnK3, I enjoy your sense of humor. You are much funnier than JohnK1 or JohnK2.

As far as Brian and the RK Rule, I have looked over the legal disclaimer on this website and I have also had my association attorney look at it, and we see no RK Rule or limit on the number of posts; so go about your posts with liberty and justice for all.

Now, how do I explain to my board the attorney charge for this? Do I just say it was an education expense?

Dana
JohnK3 (Pennsylvania)
Posts: 967
Posted:
errata:

I was, of course, referring to the "RW" Rule, not he "RK" Rule, of which I have no knowledge nor reference.

Also, my reference to "feather" was used as a generality, not in reference to the specific bird to which I referred.

I have never seen a post from JohnK1 nor JohnK2.

Note to Dana:

We have a Misc/Unknown/Underfunded line in our budget which could cover legal expenses.

And thank you for being amused.
DanaB1 (Connecticut)
Posts: 319
Posted:
JohnK the 3rd,

I did mean the RW rule and not RK, my apologies. Not that I know what RW means either.

Dana
AnnaD2 (Florida)
Posts: 960
Posted:
RW said on a previous thread that we should all stop posting after six replies to a thread. Too many ideas and too much discussion. I guess those of us who work can't reply to posts (after work) if they've already reached the six posting limits.

Of course that doesn't work. RW always has some great comments....and I believe some of his have have been 7th or 8th. We really don't want to stop posting. Sometimes it take 20 or 30 replies before SOMEONE hits it on the head!
DonnaS (Tennessee)
Posts: 5,671
Posted:

Anna,
Thanks for another very wise perspective to this. I remember one of your threads that was --mmmm-- maybe 30 replies? Once in a while, some of us try to lighten up a serious subject or try to derail something when it gets too serious. Maybe that's wrong but maybe not for everyone. We just have to remember that this is not a legal forum but just opinions and yes we do get derailed sometimes. But if someone are looking for serious, legal advice, then maybe LAW.com or another site is better.

It's nice that we have George to inform us of the law when needed and we also appreciate some subjects that tax our brains less. Put it all together and this is not a bad place to come for free advice on simple HOA matters. That's what we do best but once in a while, it is not a bad thing to let loose a little.
DwightT (Idaho)
Posts: 664
Posted:
Donna - nice timing for this. There was an article in today's paper about rain water harvesting: http://www.idahostatesman.com/localnews/story/564279.html
One of the things I found interesting was that in Colorado, you don't have to worry about the HOA complaining about a rain barrel because the state will come after you. "In Colorado, guiding water from a roof or downspout to anywhere other than the ground, like a barrel or cistern, can result in a $500 fine." I can kind of understand it because of water-rights issues (water rights can be a big deal in the dryer parts of the country), but I think the states that have these restrictions have kind of missed the point here. It would seem to me that people who use rainwater would be using less water from the rest of the system.
DonnaS (Tennessee)
Posts: 5,671
Posted:

Dwight,
Studies have shown that more than 50% of treated water use goes to lawns and landscape use. This number is only getting higher every year and it taxes city water systems greatly so we need to do something about it.

I find it ironical that Colorado will fine someone for diverting downspout water when it was the U. of Colorado that researched and coined the term "Xeriscape" The question is why would they do that.
BobS10 (Connecticut)
Posts: 39
Posted:
Very interesting concept here!
Our association recently contracted to have our gutters cleaned (townhouses) and discovered that our system goes into dry wells which are clogged and hence the expense will be considerably more than what was budgeted.
In addition, we just got hit with a significant increase from our municipal water department.
I'm thinking a rain barrel system would kill two birds, negate cleaning out the drywells and conserve on water for sprinklering the lawns.
BUT, I'm wondering, what happens to all that water in the barrels in the winter when everything freezes?
And if the water goes elsewhere in the winter, where does it go?
Most of our water damage problems happen in the winter when things freeze, then you get a rainstorm and the water has no where to go.
DonnaS (Tennessee)
Posts: 5,671
Posted:

Bob, Being that I am originally from Wisconsin, I know that you have to empty any vessel or recepticle with standing water. Birdbaths, sprinkler bibs, etc, you know the procedure. Check with your local Master Gardener group sponsered thru the U. of Conn and they could provide you with some information.

Rain barrels hold enough water to wet down a 10 x 10 garden.
MaryA1 (Arizona)
Posts: 7,043
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By BobS10 on 12/03/2008 12:23 PM
Very interesting concept here!
Our association recently contracted to have our gutters cleaned (townhouses) and discovered that our system goes into dry wells which are clogged and hence the expense will be considerably more than what was budgeted.
In addition, we just got hit with a significant increase from our municipal water department.
I'm thinking a rain barrel system would kill two birds, negate cleaning out the drywells and conserve on water for sprinklering the lawns.
BUT, I'm wondering, what happens to all that water in the barrels in the winter when everything freezes?
And if the water goes elsewhere in the winter, where does it go?
Most of our water damage problems happen in the winter when things freeze, then you get a rainstorm and the water has no where to go.

Bob,

IMO, some research is required b/4 undertaking the project of installing rain barrels on each townhouse. Who is going to empty the barrels and at what cost? What will be the procedure for using the water to water grass, trees and plants and who will perform the task and at what cost? What will be the exact savings on the water bill? Rainwater will still fall in areas where there are no rain barrels and flow into the areas where the dry wells are located. Therefore, the dry wells will still have to be cleaned periodically. Be careful that this plan is not "penny-wise, pound-foulish".
DonnaS (Tennessee)
Posts: 5,671
Posted:

Mary,
When anyone consideres the alternative to using city water for yard use, they should do their homework. A single rain barrel will not water a lawn. Their purpose is to water plants, containers and small areas. Use of them is an alternative to daily watering of small areas. One does not empty the barrel if you are using it as it is intended. It costs around $10 to 12 bucks to retrofit one for garden use. 55 gallon barrels can water patio or deck plants for a couple of weeks or until it rains again.
MaryA1 (Arizona)
Posts: 7,043
Posted:
Donna,

Thx! You've reinforced my point quite nicely! :-)
DonnaS (Tennessee)
Posts: 5,671
Posted:

Mary,
Yup, that's what we do, support each other.
RobertR1 (South Carolina)
Posts: 5,164
Posted:
Ok H20 groupies, fill in the blanks from this old song that I can't remember the words to but it had the following in there somewhere.

"Slide down my rain barrel (correct sp), climb up my cellar door, and we'll be Jolly Friends for ever more." That's all I remember, but thanks all for sticking this in my brain and leaving it there for me to fuss with.

And I have fond and not so fond memories of the original wooden staved (correct sp) barrel that sat on on my back porch too many years ago. Alongside it was a bench with a basin, a bar of soap, a face cloth and a towel. Refreshing during the summer, in the winter, not so much, as you might have to crack the ice to get to the water.
DanaB1 (Connecticut)
Posts: 319
Posted:
Robert,

Here is a website for that song............

http://kids.niehs.nih.gov/lyrics/playmate.htm

Dana
DonnaS (Tennessee)
Posts: 5,671
Posted:

Dwight,
Thanks for this link. I forwarded it to our County AG Agent. He will edit it down and put it in our newsletter. Many of the "Rainbarrel Ambassadors" get asked questions when we are out in the field doing the classes and this article does answer some of those. Again--THANKS!
RobertR1 (South Carolina)
Posts: 5,164
Posted:
Thanks to all. Now that I know and recall more about it, I wonder what I want to know for. Anyone still have a cellar door, where the snakes use to curly up in the sun and a frog or two hoping AROUND IN THE SHADE?
PattiM (Arizona)
Posts: 13
Posted:
Great thread. I have been thinking about rain barrels for a while now and was wondering why rain barrels have to look like barrels at all? Couldn't they just as easily be made to look like a column that could even be painted the same color as the residence or trim color? Or a planter?

Is an injection molding company one that would fabricate something like this?

I was thinking that if my rain barrel would have a soaker hose attachment with spigot at the bottom, it could be used to water the plantings around the sides of my home, saving the sprinklers for the lawn itself.
RobertR1 (South Carolina)
Posts: 5,164
Posted:
PattiM,
I am afraid someone has beat you to this idea of decrotive Rain Barrels.

Check out Google of Wikopedia for "Rain Barrels."
DonaldM3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 132
Posted:
The rain barrel idea was a very appealing idea to conserve some H2O for garden watering until I checked out the prices - $150.00 and up. Me thinks it will take me a few years to save enough water to pay that off; I think I’ll stick to the wasteful method for now!

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here