💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

TeresaH4 (Florida)
Posts: 2
Posted:
Hello, Our HOA needs help with alot of questions re: our BOD and management. We believe that there is a lot of illegal things they are doing but we need to know for sure. Here are a few examples.

I have a question I hope you can answer for me. Last January 2007 our Home Owners Association
Had the regular scheduled members meeting for our elections? However there was not enough to have a Quorum. Can you tell me if the people that ran for office seats on the board were elected there legally?
In other words should they have had another meeting to get a quorum?
I really need some help with this Association. They do so many illegal things. I do not know who to report them to. Can you help me with that? Is there some type of investigation that the State can step in and check on them? E.G.: they hire lawn people who have **NO workers compensation insurance and the lawn people hire residents to work their machinery and pay them on the side. Isn't this putting our Association at risk for insurance problems? (**I have just learned that the lawn company finally got their insurance.)
They forge signatures on petitions (the President) as to which I have proof of. And the managment company was aware of this but did nothing. They said the petition was to still go out.
They have been running a 7 person board with only 4 people since Sept of 07 because 3 board members resigned because they didn't like what was going on. They never tried to replace them at all. There is so much I can go on and on. But let's try one at a time.

So for now.

MY MAIN QUESTION IS WAS THIS ELECTION LEGAL?
I would appreciate any help you can give me. Our New elections are coming up and I feel we are going to have the same problem.
PeterB1 (Florida)
Posts: 257
Posted:
It seems you have answered your own question. You said there was NOT a quorum. If there was no quorum, then no business could be conducted, legally at the meeting. Hence, the officers were not legally elected.

If you are not sure IF there was a quorum, check your governing documents.
RobertR1 (South Carolina)
Posts: 5,164
Posted:
Theresa,
Tell us if you are a Lone Ranger or do you have some supporting network. Say, all you say is true; you will need power to move the present Board. Power is members, power is organization, power is doing the right thing and money may be needed. Don't beat a dead dog, network the neighbors, don't do it alone, work until you all feel comfortable walking into a Board meeting, call a point of order and get it all on the table in an open venue. Then go back with your group and see what you got, maybe you all can work together if you all would be convinced that the thing you all have in common is to "Protect the Real Property" of your association. That is step #1. Nothing else should be on anyone's agenda other than step #1.

It's not complicated. It is just like your home, protect the family and what the family has. Protect the association and what the association has.
Your documents are of great importance and demand the respect of all. The documents are also flexible and can be changed (attitude adjustment).
SusanW1 (Michigan)
Posts: 5,202
Posted:
Check your bylaws under Elections or Terms of Office. It MAY say that terms of office for the board are for a certain time period OR until the next election. So if the election is delayed, then the current board stays in office.

In any case, you did not hold the annual meeting (i.e. conduct the business of the annual meeting) since there was not a quorum. You need to rally the members and find out why they are not attending this very important meeting. Insist that another date be set.

As for vacancies, look in the bylaws to see how to fill vacancies, or how many people comprise the board. If it says 4 to 7, then they can operate with the 4 for as long as they wish. If there is a definite minimum number stated, they must fill those vacancies.
GloriaM (North Carolina)
Posts: 829
Posted:
Tereasa:

A quorum is not only met by the attendance of persons, but by proxy ballot. Therefore if they had enough proxies to reach the required quorum, then it was legal.

Perhaps you should run for the board so that you can see if your suspicions are correct. Many HO's believe there is illegal activity because they do not know and see all of things that go on behind the scenes.
PaulM (Pennsylvania)
Posts: 1,347
Posted:
GloriaM: Your response is taken to heart since things are not always as they seem. Indeed you are correct and it is good we are all reminded of that occasionally. A Happy and Blessed New Year to You!
RaymondC (Minnesota)
Posts: 64
Posted:
I wasn't there, but many associations have a rule that if a quorum is not aviailable at a meeting, a reduced number is quorum for the next meeting, often working down to just a couple of people. What was the quorum status of the previous several meetings, and what do you documents say about this?

And, as another poster has pointed out, don't overlook proxies.

I think too, you would be much happier if you looked at the needs of your association, and then how well the board is meeting them. That's why they are there, not to be second guessed on everything they do. I would never say we would ever now, or ever did not follow the law in all particulars, but sometimes it's more important to get a job done and at a reasonable time and cost. Maybe, if they are doing a good job, you might cut them a bit more slack before you form your judgments.

Finally, the best way to make sure things go as close to the way you want them as they can, you can get on the board. Few associations are overwhelmed by candidates, and few sitting back judging have the first clue about the nature or extent of the effort and committment that the board requires to function at all.

Food for thought....
TeresaH4 (Florida)
Posts: 2
Posted:
Thank you all for the feedback. There was NO quorum. Even with the proxies. As for running for the board I was one who was elected. Unfortunatly I had to resign because this board is just unreal. Itis a seven member board but they have the controlling side. The POA does noting but lie and I don't know how they do it but they have the mngmnt company go along with them. They started such rumors and gave me so much grief that I resigned. The PPOA was spending money foolishly to get me off the board. I was tired of our community suffering to pay these bills so I resigned. NOt only did I resign I purchased another home and moved out. I still have my Townhouse and rent it and I am still active on other projects in the community. I am trying to get some members together.There are plenty who are fed up but they say they have been fighting this BOD for years and they never win. Like I said this BOD has been balanced to a side of 4. They change things in the documents to fit their needs but yet they never actually change the documents to make it legal. I Have paperwork that proves that the POA lies and that she has people forge petitions and the list goes on and on. There is plenty more. I was hoping that someone could tell me if there was someone that this can be reported to. Maybe someone in the state. But I do not know where to start.Any input would be appreciated.

RobertR1 (South Carolina)
Posts: 5,164
Posted:
Teresa,
Let's be blunt. DO NOT post allegations of illegal acts on the Internet.
Period.

Do you want someone to solve your problems? Is that what you are asking?

Or do you want to know how your association with the concern of the owners can solve their problems?

Do you all feel you must go to the courts or do you want to take a stand and stop letting someone push you all around?

You say there are plenty of concerned people there that don't like what is going on. Get them together, hear what they have to say, form an organization, produce a mission statement, and do it all in the open. Elect officers, assign tasks to many, have another meeting, start an e-mail circle, talk openly about it but do not accuse. Instead of old what's her name did..........say; I think we should follow our supporting documents and request to look at certain books of the association, who wants to find out how we do this?

Incidently, your PM works for the Board, not the other way around, and they are using your money to do it.

Get some organization started and do this thing right, don't shoot yourselve in the foot, and we can help in the process.
PaulM (Pennsylvania)
Posts: 1,347
Posted:
TeresaH4: You have placed yourself in a very sensitive situation. You were elected to the Board but resigned due to control issues; you were so frustrated with the Board..."I purchased another home and moved out. I still have my Townhouse and rent it and I am still active on other projects in the community." You want to 'help' but you don't want to live there!

There are those who will disagree, but IMHO, let those who live there rally
together for change to occur. You will have enough headaches in ensuring your 'renter' follows the rules so that You will not be sent violation notices! Good Luck!

GloriaM (North Carolina)
Posts: 829
Posted:
There are 3 sayings that I like that relates to HOA's and voluteering for board positions or committees. Teresa IMHO by staying on the board and finding ways to resolve the issue would have been the better way of making an impact within the community.

You would have been privy to those "behind the scenes" things that I spoke about in my previous post. It is those people who when it gets tough, the tough get going. It is always easier to ridicule, then to hang in there during the tough times and make a difference in the community. Its a thankless job, but its your investment.

“Good people do not need laws to tell them to act responsibly, while bad people will find a way around the laws” - Plato 427-347 BD

“Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful committed citizens can change the world. Indeed it is the only thing that ever has." - Margaret Mead

“All truth passes through 3 phases: First, it is ridiculed. Second, it is violently opposed, and Third, it is accepted as self-evident.” — Arthur Schopenhauer
BruceC2 (Virginia)
Posts: 54
Posted:
Theresa i dont believe you need a quoram for the annual elections every homeowner needs to be notified that the meeting is to elect officers and board members. A quoram is to establish that a majority of homeowners are present to declair a quoram that the vote of which whatever by-laws or restrictions they want to change, delete or place in the community had by either proxy or presence of a homeowner was presented. (EXAMPLE) My homeowners last meeting had 32 of 55 represented by attendence or proxy being thier was a majority of eligable homeowners present to vote the majority of the vote taken then becomes law reguardless of those that did not cast a vote. These are not confidential votes and should lead to your other question if you have proof of names being added to the elections use it a proxy or name added to a vote should be shown by letter or petition at the time of the vote
PaulM (Pennsylvania)
Posts: 1,347
Posted:
TeresaH4: Since concerns are still present over last year's election, and you are afraid the 'same problem' will occur for this year's election, why not offer to be part of the appointed committee to oversee the election process? That way, your membership as an owner, though not on-site, still affords you the 'hands on' of a legal and proper election.

Your docs may dictate the election process to follow for your assn and if you were involved, you could ensure they are carried out. If no process is dictated, it is always well to appoint residents to act as vote-counter and vote-recorder to tally the votes at the meeting--but obviously, not to appoint one who is also a Board-nominee. Something to consider....

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here