๐Ÿ’ฌ Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account โ†’

โšก Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

BrendaM5 (California)
Posts: 7
Posted:
Hi,

We just had an election on 1/3/12 to vote on the restating of our CC&R's and Bylaws
472 ballots were sent out we received 221 back which in essence was 16 votes short
for the requirements to pass or fail or the majority of the Voting Power.
Current law states
"Extended Voting. Because of the high approval requirements found in older documents (often 75%), it will be difficult to obtain the necessary number of ballots. The Inspector of Elections may extend balloting one or more times to solicit ballots from apathetic voters. Civil Code ยง1363.03(c)(3)(f)&(h)."

The Board President stated he felt they needed at least 350 ballots to pass and the Board Not The Inspector of Elections made a resolution to extend voting but did not put a time limit on it The President and I use the term loosley wants it to pass and it seems as if he will wait until he gets the ballots he feels will pass the propsed documents. My husband who was at the meeting informed the Board it was the Inspector of Elections who was in charge but they just ignored my husband. So everyone left the meeting without resolution of how long he is going to wait before continuing the vote counting. Does anyone have any idea of how long the vote can be suspened is it just until a mority of the ballots come in?

Any thoughts would be appreciated.

Thank you,
B

JeffR7 (California)
Posts: 251
Posted:
Brenda, were the 221 submitted ballots opened and counted? If so I don't think you can extend the deadline. If, however, they weren't counted it is up to the Board to extend the deadline. Inspector's role is to make sure that ballots are secret, valid, and properly counted. An inspector doesn't run elections, but only reports back the result.

I think it's counterproductive not to have a deadline. When people know there is no deadline they are not in any rush to comply and so it will take a long time.
BrendaM5 (California)
Posts: 7
Posted:
Hi,

No the votes were unopened and not counted and the Inspectorrr has them in his possession which is how it should be. It is just frustrating because the 1st election was cancelled altogther when angry residents found out what was in the documents even though the Board President was touting them as fabulous. They redid the docs and they did remove some things but then they added more rules
which were even worse in my opinion. Our neighborhood has been here since 1954 and is made up of 468 single family homes, 9 - 6 unit apartment builings and 10- 2unit duplexes. We have 1 pool and 2 parks as our only common area. The only restricitons we had persay was to pay your assessment and follow the regulation set forth by Local and State Laws and that was about it.
The documents that were drafted were boiler plate condo rules and regs
which did not really fit with our unique neighborhood. They want to tell people who have lived here since 1960 what color thier house can be painted. Ugh
BrendaM5 (California)
Posts: 7
Posted:
Also please note: Of all of the 221 votes that were received and the 16 additional votes needed every one of them would have to have been a Yes vote in order to pass which is Extremely unlikely if not impossible. That's why I wanted to know how long he can troll for votes until he gets the number he believes can
pass. Seems shady to me although maybe not to others.
SusanW1 (Michigan)
Posts: 5,202
Posted:
Brenda - I guess I missed the back story about your situation. But usually, the CCRs are automatically extended UNLESS there is a vote to disband. That voting threshold is set very high. It's not a light decision to disband the HOA.

Could you explain why you need this high threshold APPROVAL vote at this time?

BrendaM5 (California)
Posts: 7
Posted:
Hi Susan,

Our governing documents are original from 1954 and the date that they could have been first changed was Jan. 1978. If 6 months prior to Jan 1978
they could have first been amended with 50% of the owners giving their written approval and then recorded. If nothing was done they would run for subsequent 10 year periods at which time the approval to amend, change, or cancel would require
a 75% owner approval of such action. Well as you know there are new laws the Election law is one of them so the Board was going to have the documents restated
but what they did was actually get rid of all of our CC&R's and replace it with
a boiler plate condo rules. The new one changed the language, changed our definitions of our housing which (by the way was always accourding to City Municipal code) of what we originally had and some of it is not even law or does not even pertain to us just rules and regulations. Anyway the courts have rules to amend or Restate and you must have more than 50% of the owners voting in the affirmative.
There are some of us who beleive that we missed our 10 year window which would have
been 2008 follwed by 2018. There is so much back story here I assure you.
TimB4 (Tennessee)
Posts: 21,047
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By BrendaM5 on 01/05/2012 3:39 PM
That's why I wanted to know how long he can troll for votes until he gets the number he believes can pass.

Brenda,

The Davis-Stirling web site discusses this on it's Closing & Reopening the Polls web page. Per that page they identify the conflict and even state that "Boards of directors will need to decide how to address this issue through their Election Rules with the advice of the association's legal counsel." Therefore, it appears it's confusing even for the legal professionals.

I'm curious about the language in your documents that have you believe you may only amend them once every 10 years. If possible, would you post that section?

I ask because even though most CC&Rs auto renew every 10 years, they may be amended at anytime providing the votes are there to amend.

BrendaM5 (California)
Posts: 7
Posted:
I guess my question really is if when they continue the election at the next meeting and 16 ballots come in thereby fullfilling the 50% do the votes have to be counted or can the President who is choosing to postpone not the Inspector
wait until he gets 100 more ballots in?
The CC&R's I have are in the form of a PDF
document can I just attach the whole file for you and site the page # so you can read it- it's pretty wordy?
SusanW1 (Michigan)
Posts: 5,202
Posted:
Brenda - how do you know you need 16 more votes to pass this?

The ballots must NOT be opened and counted - and then the vote postponed until enough yes votes come in so it can pass. That is not the intent in extending a voting time period.

BrendaM5 (California)
Posts: 7
Posted:
Hi,

In order for the propostion to have passed the affirmative vote of of not less than a majority of the voting power
would have to voted yes. The voting power defined was at least 1/2 of owners entitled to cast a vote. 472 Owners were entitled to vote. 221 sent in ballots More than a majority would be 237 and all of them would of had to be yes votes which is unlikely.The ballots were not opened but the President knows it did not pass and is seeking 100 more ballots. So what I am saying is we received back less than 1/2 of the ballots sent out by 16
CarolR11 (Colorado)
Posts: 2,563
Posted:
It's also possible, Brenda, that some of the ballots cast may be invalid, which is up to the Inspector of Election to determine. The most common reasons in our HOA is when h'owner do not fill out the return address info on the outside envelope or fail to sign it.
BrendaM5 (California)
Posts: 7
Posted:
The Inspector already removed all ineleigible envelopes (which contain ballots) that did not have
a signed signature on the envelope or address which identifies the property to which the vote is for. So once the actual secret ballots is opened there could be some that were not marked or spoiled I suppose.

๐ŸŽฏ You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • โœ“ Ask follow-up questions
  • โœ“ Share your experience
  • โœ“ Get expert advice
  • โœ“ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account โ†’

โšก Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here